Sex- Selective Surgeries in Inter-Sex Infants and Young Children : A Human Right Issue

Authors

  • Shreyansh LL.M. Department of Law, M.D. University, Rohtak

Keywords:

Intersex, Human rights, Healthcare, Surgeries etc

Abstract

Intersex persons and bodies have always been seen as being incapable of assimilating into society. The practise of performing medical operations on often-healthy bodies to meet perceived family and cultural obligations continues despite questions about the need, consequences, conduct, and consent of such procedures. International human rights organisations and a handful of national governments have responded by issuing a slew of new policy declarations on the rights of intersex individuals, which have been endorsed by the international human rights system. However, there are significant obstacles to overcome in order to put such assertions into action. Human rights crimes against intersex persons continue to be committed, and are deeply ingrained in a long history of purposeful suppression. The rhetoric of changing healthcare procedures has not been backed up by evidence. A policy disjunction occurs when intersex problems are framed as questions of “sexual orientation and gender identity rather than as matters of intrinsic sex characteristics; this has resulted in rhetoric of inclusion that does not match the reality.

References

J A Grennberg, ‘International Legal Developments Protecting the Autonomy Rights of Sexual Minorities’ in S E Sytsma (ed) Ethics and Intersex (2006), p 87.

K J Zucker, ‘Gender Identity and Intersexuality’ in S E Sytsma (ed) Ethics and Intersex (2006), p 165.

A C Lareau, ‘Who decides? Genital-Normalizing Surgery on Intersex Infants’ (2003 Nov) 92(1), Georgetown Law Journal, p 129.

K Parlett and K Weston-Scheuber, ‘Consent to treatment for transgender and intersex children’ (2004) 9(2) Deakin Law Review, p 375.

Department of Health & Community Services v JWB & SMB (1992), 175 CLR 218 (Marion’s Case), 2009).

Holmes M. The Intersex Enchiridion: Naming and Knowledge. Somatechnics, September 2011;1(2):388–411.

Yoosuf M. Recognition and protection for intersex persons. Law Institute Journal, April 2015:52–56.

Ghattas DC. Standing up for the human rights of intersex people. ILGA-Europe, OII Europe: Brussels, 2015.

Cabral M. The marks on our bodies. Intersex Day. 2015 [cited 25 October 2015].

Reardon S. The spectrum of sex development: Eric Vilain and the intersex controversy. Nature, 2016;533(7602):160–163.

Virginia Braun, et al., “Thematic analysis”. In Poul Rohleder, and Antonia C. Lyons, eds. Qualitative research in clinical and health psychology. Palgrave Macmillan, 2014.

Jörg Woweries. “Intersexualität: Eine kinderrechtliche Perspektive.” (2011)

Downloads

Published

2018-03-30

How to Cite

Shreyansh. (2018). Sex- Selective Surgeries in Inter-Sex Infants and Young Children : A Human Right Issue. Innovative Research Thoughts, 4(3), 382–389. Retrieved from https://irt.shodhsagar.com/index.php/j/article/view/1357